Mulan: Live Action
One must know how deeply disappointing it is to wait, what feels like an eternity, for a new live-action remake of a movie to just be so dismaying. This movie was so hyped by many and watching the previews/trailers got everyone all riled up; many were counting down the days until it was released. That feeling of utter despair after watching it all the way through, mixed with it not meeting our expectations, is very disheartening. For me, that movie was the new live action remake of Mulan. I, and so many others like my family, had such high hopes just to have it crushed.
In the animated version of the movie, it had Mushu the red dragon, the “lucky cricket”, and Mulan’s grandma which was not featured in the live-action remake of the movie. In my opinion, those three were the highlight of the movie. Mushu and the cricket were my personal favorite characters and made the animated version a lot better than the remake. One of my favorite traits about Mushu was that he had such a huge ego for how small of a dragon he was. All the ancestors of Mulan would make fun and laugh at him for how small he was. They didn’t believe in him when he said that he would be the one to watch over Mulan and protect her. This only enhanced my appeal to Mushu. His humor was elite and accentuated the movie a lot.
The “lucky cricket” was another one of my favorite characters. Although he never said anything, he still had a big impact on the movie. He was the one who traveled with Mushu and Mulan everywhere they went. He was the one character in the movie that came so close to death multiple times and never ended up dying. At the beginning of the movie, Mushu didn’t really like him so much, but Mushu had started to like him by the time the movie was about to get to the halfway point.
Then, in the remake of the movie there were lots of things that I didn’t like about it. Just a few of them were that there was no Mushu, “lucky cricket”, grandma, and they changed the hawk into a witch. Although they still had a Phoenix which was supposed to be the guardian just like Mushu, but it just wasn’t the same. I personally thought changing the hawk into a shape-shifting witch was kind of pointless. It really didn’t add much to the story other than the fact that she related to Mulan, tried to get her to join her, and take over the whole empire.
I feel as if the remake would have been more enjoyable and humorous if those important helping characters were not taken out of it. If cricket, Mushu, and grandma were still featured in the movie, then I would have enjoyed it much better. Another major shift was the fact that there was little to none love interest as there was in the original movie. Not that I am all for sappy chick-flicks, but it would have been nice to see some enticement between Mulan and the soldier. In the original, the “love interest” was the general and not just another fellow soldier.
In conclusion, I would not really recommend it to anyone unless they are a diehard Disney princess fan. The movie was not terrible, but improvements could definitely have been made: especially if the three characters I mentioned were added in. In my opinion, I have seen much better movies and maybe I just had too high of expectations for Mulan. All in all, I felt as if something was missing all throughout watching the movie, but it did not end up being horrible. I just wish they had kept some of the key parts in there from the original rather than switching it all up on us.
Ryleigh mabus • Feb 24, 2021 at 9:59 am
i’m glad i’m not the only person that was sad they didn’t add Mushu and the lucky cricket and took out the love connection in the movie to. But knowing that they took out the grandma made it worst and knowing they changed they hawk. Thank you for your opinion in this and saying what else was different because i thought about watching it the other day and knowing they tookout more than what they were suppost to makes me sad.
Kennedy McLaughlin • Dec 8, 2020 at 9:43 am
I definitely agree with you. The character Mushu was my favorite part in the original movie. I also missed the lack of songs. What made the first movie so good was all the songs and dancing. Without the songs it made the movie a lot more serious.
Katie Hurst • Nov 30, 2020 at 10:03 am
I just watched the live action version, and I definitely agree with your opinion. The three characters would have made the movie more interesting and fun. Great article!
Jack Salyers • Sep 24, 2020 at 7:53 am
Great article Braxton! I really liked how you described the movie and all the in’s and outs of this film. With this amazing article I may have to go see this movie. Keep up the good work.
Bianca Panmei • Sep 23, 2020 at 10:07 am
I agree with your opinion. I think Mushu, “lucky cricket”, and the grandma should’ve been in the remake. I was looking forward to seeing those three in the movie. I was very interested in your article while I was reading it. Keep up the great work.
Preston Parker • Sep 21, 2020 at 2:41 pm
I never watched the original Mulan, but at least I know I should steer clear of the live action remake. Ive heard even worse things about the production and filming locations for this movie and I genuinely don´t have faith for any more live action remakes produced by Disney any longer.
Enoch Hines • Sep 21, 2020 at 2:10 pm
Great article Brax! I have not yet watched Mulan but thank you for describing a little about the movie. If I get the chance to watch it I’ll make sure to. Your review was well written and it seems you put some effort into it. Keep up the great writing.
Madison Cummins • Sep 21, 2020 at 8:09 am
This is such a great article! I feel that you have a very educated and intelligent opinion. I have not been able to watch this movie, but it is disappointing to hear how the new animated movie is not as good as expected. Personally, I feel that most remakes of movies are much better when the main characters are not changed so much. Keep up the good writing!
Nathaniel Moss • Sep 18, 2020 at 8:07 am
Nice work! I haven’t seen this movie but I have been wanting to so it’s nice to read this article. I watched the preview and was pretty impressed. Great article keep it up!
Kurtis Goodwin • Sep 17, 2020 at 9:54 pm
I feel you the live action was a bit of a let down. There is actually a reason why there was no love interest in the live action (No idea why they didn’t include Mushu the “Lucky Cricket” or the grandma they were the best part of the og film.) it was because they were trying to be more historically accurate maybe that is why there was no grandma, Mushu, or cricket.
Maryn Zeck • Sep 17, 2020 at 12:29 pm
I totally agree with you! I think Mushu, Lucky Cricket, and Mulan’s Grandma needed to be in the new movie. I loved the animated Mulan and Mushu’s personality so much that I was very disappointed when he wasn’t included in the new movie. Still a very great article!!
vade sullivan • Sep 17, 2020 at 10:57 am
I think this what a great article and very imformative. I have not seen the movie yet, only the animated version, but reading that the dragon, lucky cricket, and mulans grandma not being in the movie I almost don’t want to watch it.
Eliana Cicalo • Sep 17, 2020 at 10:19 am
I think this what a great article and very imformative. I have not seen the movie yet, only the animated version, but reading that the dragon, lucky cricket, and mulans grandma not being in the movie I almost don’t want to watch it. I think mushu is such a big part of the movie, and I was really disappointed to read that he was not apart of it. However this was a great article just disappointed in disney on this one.
Eliana Cicalo • Sep 17, 2020 at 10:15 am
I think this what a great article and very imformative. I have not seen the movie yet, only the animated version, but reading that the dragon, lucky cricket, and mulans grandma not being in the movie I almost don’t want to watch it. I think mushu is such a big part of the movie, and I was really disappointed to read that he was not apart of it. However this was a great article just disappointed in disney on this one.
Jarin Williams • Sep 17, 2020 at 8:30 am
Great article! I have to agree that removing Mushu made the movie not as likable.
Olivia Packard • Sep 15, 2020 at 8:08 am
Amazing article! I do agree with you, I don’t like it when live action version of movies switch it up and are different from the original movie. I haven’t seen the movie yet, but I probably won’t end up watching it.
Rochelle Pense • Sep 15, 2020 at 7:56 am
Great article! I really love some of the live action version of the animated versions like Cinderella, but when I saw the trailer I wasn’t as excited. Mushu is also one of my favorite characters, and he really makes the movie what it is. I think they did a good job trying to make it more accurate, but they still need the whole Disney feel to it. Keep up the good work.
Bella Panmei • Sep 14, 2020 at 2:11 pm
Great article Brax! I agree with your poinst and I miss all those characters too. The grandma was a great addition to the first one and I feel like the live action movie could have been so much better if they did not take out those specific characters. Keep up the awesome writing!